Let me begin by saying: These are different. Not only are they marketed differently, but they perform differently on the lips as well. To be more precise, I find the different shades in the own brand vary in formula and finish as well. So, please don't think these are close dupes as I compare them side by side. I put these together in 1 post just because they are very, very similar in packaging.
Clinique, Chubby Stick Moisturizing Lip Colour Balm. I have the shades #04 Mega Melon and #05 Chunky Cherry. Highly adore and appreciate the alliteration in their naming! Both of these are gift with purchase sizes, which I obtained them from local beauty stores (Aster, it is).
Revlon, Just Bitten Kissable Balm Stain. I have the shades #001 Honey, #015 Cherish and #045 Romantic. They are sold at HKD $98 (USD $12.6) and currently on promotion for HKD $78 (USD $10). Still, this is way more expensive than what you need to pay for in the States!
Mega Melon is a very natural beige with hint of orange. Not an easy shade to describe. It has some very fine shimmer/frost in it.
Chunky Cherry is a pinkish red. It has a sheer, clear finish. The picture didn't do it justice. It is even brighter in reality. Instantly brighten up the complexion and adds fun and colour to the look. *Sorry my photo was out of focus*
Honey is a medium mauve pink. It is basically satin, with a hint of pearl finish.
Cherish is a pastel pink, with a lot of white and blue tones showing through. It applies very thickly and I'm sad to say it leans on the chalky side.
Romantic is a red. It has slight brick or orange tone in it. Still sheer and not too grown up. The balm texture on this is the best out of the 3 I own.
Revlon on the left, Clinique on the right.
Comparison:
Origin: Clinique made in Canada, Revlon made in USA.
Colour selection: Clinique 16 shades, Revlon 8 shades. (In Hong Kong)
Moisture: Both are very good. I can apply both on dry bare lips and not feel uncomfortable. Clinique does have more balm/gloss feel to it, so I will say it is more moisturising. Revlon gives a more "moisturising lipstick" feeling, which is smooth and perfect initially. Throughout the wear, the Clinique feels more comfy compared to the Revlon.
Scent: Clinique is fragrance and scent free. Revlon has a rather strong mint scent, which is gone in a few minutes, at most 10. I can't tell which mint it is, but I can tell I don't like it!
Pigmentation: Revlon definitely pays off more, on hand and on lips. It can cover my medium-pigmented lips. totally. Clinique is semi-sheer.
Lasting power: Both are decent.
Stain: Clinique almost doesn't leave a stain, perhaps a faint one for the Chunky Cherry. Revlon, on the other hand, all leaves quite a distinct stain. However, the pinks do not leave the same shade of pink stain when they fade. That is, the stain differs from the balm colour.
My favourite:
For natural everyday colour, I'll go for Revlon 001 Honey. A beautiful pink that flatters my complexion.
For a brighter, 'statement' lips, I'll go for Revlon 045 Romantic. It is really red, and really easy to wear in terms of red lips. Not too high-maintenance I'd say!
I prefer the Revlon ones, except for the scent. I wish we have the colour Crush in Hong Kong! :S
Beautiful wishes,
Lazy silly Jacq :")
I've been wondering how these compare, my sis has a chubby stick which is nice but I noticed the same that the revlon's have a little more colour...I think I'm gona go for Revlon too :-)
ReplyDeleteYea Yea. I have had the chubby stick in mega melon for a few months and I have only wore it out twice. They are comfortable but not phenomenal. The Revlon, on the other hand, has been on my lips and in my handbag since I got them, every day!
DeleteI have honey and sweetheart and now want cherish! It looks lovely:) let me know if you want me to send you crush:) I'd be glad to!
ReplyDeleteThank you Yessie! I dropped you an email! Please check~ Yay~ :)
Deleteyes!!!i wish the shade"crush" will land hong kong, it is a color perfect for autum
ReplyDeleteI hope I can swap one from US! :P
Deleteyes!!i wish the shade crish will land hk!!!it is a color perfect for fall!!!!
ReplyDelete